Sunday, October 19, 2008

8 Against 8

Lori, this is for you, both because you asked (or rather dropped a way for me to help into my inbox) and because it is right. Since I cannot vote in California, this is my voting in spirit:

Over the weekend, I attended the Great Lakes History Conference, which had women's history as its theme. More on that later, this post has a point -- eventually.

One of the papers on one of the panels that I chaired focused on the legal arguments surrounding the fight for woman's suffrage. One of the stragetgies of the movement involved an attempt to set a legal precendent by procuring an interpretation of the 14th Amendment. When that not only did not work, but also backfired as the courts began explicitly excluding suffrage from an understanding of citizenship in decisions that also lay the legal groundwork for Jim Crow.

The author of this paper, Annmarie Valdes, opened by drawing a connection between the rights of citizens and gay marriage. While the woman's suffrage movement had voting rights as its goal, the underlying argument for it and for later civil rights' movement relied upon the definition of "citizen," and the rights conferred with citizenship. With marriage seen as a contractual union -- also a 19th century development that another panelist examined -- and the right to enter into contracts seen as a civil right, the exclusion of a whole segment of the population from this right to enter into this marriage contract is, in fact, an infringement upon gay people's rights as citizens.

Which brings me to the point of this post. As you may know, the right of California gay couples to enter into this contract of marriage, to arrange their private lives with all of the same protections that straight couples have, is at this very moment being threatened, and threatened with all due prejudice and not a little hate. The tool of this hateful prejudice is Proposition 8.

Look at the language of the ballot, courtesy of the fabulous Lori Hahn, of Hahn at Home: "Changes California Constitution to eliminate the right of same-sex couples to marry. Provides that only marriage between a man and a woman is valid in California." In cold terms, a right is being eliminated. A right.

Sadly, the forces of ignorance seem to be ahead in California, having $10 million more to organize and "educate" support for Proposition 8, according to Equality California (as quoted in the "8 Against 8" press release by Lianne Stokes). To fight the hate, 8 lesbian bloggers -- bloggers whose civil rights are directly at stake in this election -- will be blogging about Proposition 8 for the next 8 days in an effort to raise $8 million.

Since we all can't vote in California (which suggests sort of a states' rights question waiting to be asked there), we can still demonstrate our opposition to Proposition 8 in a few ways.

First, go to Equality California's 8 Against 8 to throw a little cash their way. Every dollar counts.

Second, pass the word on to your readers.

Third, go read the blogs. You may even want to add them to your blogroll, if you haven't already:

  1. Lori Hahn, Hahn at Home
  2. Pam Spaulding, Pam's House Blend
  3. Dorothy Snarker, Dorothy Surrenders
  4. Grace Rosen and Grace Chu, Grace the Spot
  5. Kelly Leszczynski, The Lesbian Lifestyle
  6. Sinclair, Sugarbutch Chronicles
  7. Renne Gannon, Lesbiatopia
  8. Riese, This Girl Called Automatic Win
Remember what the great, gay, black, Civil Right Activist, Bayard Rustin, said: "The barometer of where one is on human rights questions is no longer the black community, it's the gay community. Because it is the community which is most easily mistreated."


Grace C. said...

hey thanks for the link to - but check your HTML code. the link isn't working.

Clio Bluestocking said...

Hi Grace! No problem linking -- especially now that I've fixed the links. Thanks for catching that!

As I told Lori: grind those bastards into the ground!

Roxie Smith Lindemann said...

Hooray -- Glad to see the big girls' blogs are taking this on. Thanks for publicizing the effort. Now, wouldn't it be nice if Obama would be willing to put some of his 16.5% lead in CA to good use by publicly campaigning against Prop 8??? I won't hold my breath, but a girl can dream.

Clio Bluestocking said...

Oh, Roxie, I cringe when the Democrats can't simply say, "yes, I support gay marriage." They don't want to offend a bunch of bigots over something so trivial as someone's right.

dykewife said...

just a little bit about the enfranchisement of canadian women...

a woman remembers nellie mcclung's mock parliament and some of the history surrounding the enfranchisement of women in manitoba and a year later in saskatchewan.

then there's a cbc vignette broadcast periodically.

rights are things that are necessarily hard fought for and must be defended vigourously. it goes for the right to vote, the right to marry who one the canadian charter of rights and freedoms says:
"...before and under the law and has the right to the equal protection and equal benefit of the law without discrimination and, in particular, without discrimination based on race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, sex, age or mental or physical disability." such holds true for everyone, regardless of the sexual orientation of the person involved.

Ann said...

Hey Clio B.--I want to hear more about the GLASA. How was Judith Zinsser's and Bonnie Smith's keynote?


Unless noted otherwise, copyright for all written content held by Clio Bluestocking.